Talk:Hurricane Retirement/@comment-27225426-20171017171226/@comment-27225426-20171017183225

Gert killed over 100 people in Mexico, just like Earl, which you agree with.

I could see why you disagree with Bertha, however, since it is the least costliest tropical cyclone on that list.

Hurricane Danny caused the worst flooding in the state of Alabama in recent history.

Tropical Storm Leslie caused $1 billion in damages to Florida. A storm back then easily got retired after causing $1 billion. This also applies to Dolly, Fay, Alex, and Lee.

Now, Tropical Storm Matthew is the one I'm surprised about the most that you disagree with. It's not normal for a storm that caused 140 fatalities to not be retired. I'm also very surprised that you disagree with Isaac. $2 billion in damages is the most that a storm has gone without being retired, excluding Karl, so I don't know how you could argue with these.