Hypothetical Hurricanes Wiki:RfCM/Cane Harvey (2)


 * You are very active on the Discord and active in wikia,also,you´re a experienced user,but I dont observed much changes in your overusing of HHW memes,also,your activity was very weird some time ago ,for that I'm neutral.  ~ Olo72  • Page • Wall •  Edits    16:26, 13 July, 2018 (UTC+1)
 * You did improve your behavior for the past months - and I congratulate you on that. You seem to be quite active on chat and on the wiki, but much of your wiki activity is limited only to your deathicane center advisories (and similar pages). Additionally, you also said in chat that your activity would be quite limited, and we need active chat moderators. You also have not exactly shown me much that you can moderate the HHW Discord server properly - and based on past circumstances, I will oppose this request. I do wish you the best of luck in this. ?? StrawberryMaster  ??  Talk |  Contributions  | 15:34, 13 Jul 2018 ?
 * While you are very active in wiki and chat, I don't believe you have all of the traits of potential administration members. You can be immature occasionally, and a lot of your chat can be spam at times. HOWEVER your HHW meme insanity has defintely died off somewhat. If you work on these issues, I will change it to support. HurricaneLaura (talk) 15:32, July 13, 2018 (UTC)
 * While you have made some gradual improvement on overall behavior, you can be immature, and you still don't seem to care about the wiki much. You have also stated you're going to be less active. I would reccomend trying to improve those things, before applying again. Best of luck. - VM (Garfield)
 * Harvey, you seem to have made some decent improvement with your behavior, and that is one thing I am very happy to see. However, you did say that you were going to become less active, which is not something I would want to see in a new chat moderator. I would reccomend improving your activity as well as on the things my colleagues have mentioned before applying again. If you improve on those things, you could expect a support vote from me. Good luck! - Cooper | Form Debby Form!
 * Harvey, you are pretty active in chat. You also seem to have improved with your usage of HHW memes. I think you do have immaturity and can be a little weird. Good Luck. - Lucarius 7/13
 * You have significantly improved on your usage of the so-called "HHW memes" which I am grateful of. However, just like what the others said above, you have mentioned that you will be less active in the wiki, and your activity before have been pretty inconsistent, which is something a chat moderator shouldn't have, and because of that, I have to vote "neutral leaning oppose". If you can fix the problems I have mentioned, then I may vote support. Good luck on your RfCM! -- Roy 25  16:09, July 13, 2018 (UTC)
 * Honestly I am neutral at this point. You seem to improve a lot, but activity is a thing that concerns me. I think you can do well as a moderator, but I suggest raising your wiki activity and chat a bit, then apply after a few weeks. Neutral for now. Best of luck! --Farm River (talk) 12:46, July 14, 2018 (UTC)
 * From what I have seen of you, you are a very active user who is active both on the main wiki and on chat. However, hearing from other users makes me realize that you were quite immature in the past. I have seen very little of that and I am a strong believer that you have the potential to be a really good chat moderator because I am an advocate for second chances. As long as you remain headed on an upwards spiral, my vote will not change. -Katagma 22:57, July 14, 2018 (UTC)
 * While you have improved greatly recently, you still are not active consistently. You have been immature in the past, and I still do not think you are quite ready to be an administration member. If you can prove to be mature and be consistently active, I may support in the future.  ~ Bobnekaro  • Page • Wall •  Edits    23:12, July 15, 2018 (UTC)
 * Like some have said above me, while you have improved a lot recently, you are not quite active enough yet. Your activity on the wiki needs to improve before I can support this. Good luck in your future endeavors. https://images.wikia.nocookie.net/hypercane/images/thumb/2/24/Signature_Icon.png/19px-Signature_Icon.png Hypercane  ( talk  ) 23:26, July 15, 2018 (UTC)
 * I am going to be honest, I disagree with some of my fellow administrators here. Your activity on the wiki looks a lot better than mine, having edited every day this month and most of the days in June. You occasionally have the 4 or so day gap in there, but so do I. As far as I have seen you are fairly active on the discord as well. Your maturity has also greatly improved since your beginning days of you on the discord. While you may have the occasional "spamfest" (and one or two minature ones in #chat), and you have made some minor mistakes in the past, we are only human. Due to the reasons I have stated, I believe I can support this request. Best of luck. ~ Akio
 * I agree with Akio with basically everything he has said above. You edit very frequently and, to me, it seems like you are trying to diversify what you edit on based on you reviving your 2018 Atlantic season. You have improved drastically in maturity since you have first joined, in my opinion. In serious situations, you are more than willing to be mature and reasonable, which is a good characteristic for a chat moderator to have. Although you have said in the past that you were going to become less active, you have both kept up your activity for now and, by saying what you said, showed me that you are responsible with your activity and will most likely not disappear without a trace (sort of like what I did in early 2017, oops). Overall, I support your request. - GaryKJR