Since Part 3 is basically dead, I've decided to revive this series with Part 4.
I'd retire:
Bret (1993 - caused 213 fatalities, including 167 fatalities in Venezuela)
Gordon (1994 - 1,000+ people killed in Haiti)
Hanna (2008 - 500+ people killed in Haiti)
I'd also unretire:
Elena (1985 - Camille and Frederic were far worse. Should replace Elsa.)
Gloria (1985 - Nothing will be worse for New England than the 1938 New England Hurricane.)
Diana (1990 - Gilbert two years earlier was far more devastating for Mexico)
Klaus (1990 - Really? France needs to get its act together)
Roxanne (1995 - Same as Diana except seven years have passed since Gilbert)
Cesar (1996 - Joan and Mitch were much worse for Central America)
Keith (2000 - Nothing will be worse than Hattie of 1961 for Belize)
Iris (2001 - See Keith)
Paloma (2008 - Only one fatality and Grand Cayman wasn't as damaged as it was in Ivan four years earlier)
Erika (2015 - David set a high bar for Dominica)
Otto (2016 - Nowhere near as bad as Joan or Mitch. Even Cesar was objectively worse for Costa Rica)
Leave your versions in the reply section.