Request Approved


WeatherWill (79.7%)

Hello HHW!

As you know, I’m Will and I’ve been a CM since December and I’m requesting rollback rights. Though many could be skeptical as I’ve been on a downward streak as of late, I assure you that that was just a result of unmotivation (from finals) and I plan to continue to work on more projects as summer rolls in (T-minus six days.)

I know there are some concerns about my moderation skills. There has been plenty of talk about me not doing well and the only reason I have for that is nothing is going on. I’ve been CM during off-season and not many new members have joined and when stuff has gone down, higher ranks have dealt with it. If this is a turn-off for my request, I one-hundred percent understand.

Thank you for reading my request and I want you to vote based on what you believe is best for the community of HHW and the discord server.

  • Symbol arrow down Neutral, leaning oppose — Hey Will. I'm going to be honest, this is a hard choice for me. I won't fully oppose this request, but I won't support it either. I could go neutral, but I feel like there is something about your current role as a chat moderator that disallows me to go full neutral, and it's what you said; your moderating. Since you were promoted, I barely saw you moderating the chat rooms and enforcing rules on misbehaving users (and by barely, I mean like 4 or 5 times). Users with rollback abilities have a higher priority than chat moderators in which they have to look after the wiki itself for any potential vandals or similar, and I do fear about your potential job as a rollback as far as what I've seen you've done regarding chat moderating rights. Other than that, there isn't any other problems I can think of on the top of my head. You've been consistently active on the wiki up until May came, and I understand your reasoning for it, and I do hope you can go back to full consistent activity sooner or later. Good luck on your RfR!  ~ Roy25   Talk | Contributions   03:33, May 18, 2019 (UTC) 
  • Symbol arrow up Neutral, leaning support — Will, you are an active and mature user. You have been a chat moderator for some time now and I think you could do a good job as rollback, however, like Roy said, you have not enforced the rules much. I understand that sometimes other users take care of it, but if you were to be a rollback, you would need to be ready to revert any vandalism. I also understand your recent less activity, but I think your activity should get back to normal soon, which would be active enough for a rollback. Good luck on the RfR! ~ Bobnekaro PageWallEdits 03:37, May 18, 2019 (UTC)
  • Symbol support vote Support — Well Will, I believe you have done well as a User here overall as far as Maturity, knowledge of the rules, activity, editing and all that goes. Per stated above, your ability to enforce these rules is still not 100% ensured in me. Overall, I have no other doubts in my mind that you are a good candidate for becoming a Rollback. Best of Luck! Lucarius ~ May 18, 2019(UTC), May 17, 2019(MST)
  • Symbol support vote Support — Overall Will, you've been a good user and chat moderator during your time here on HHW. You've shown that you are mature and capable of enforcing the rules. Much like everyone else has stated here, you do not enforce the rules very often, however I am hoping that as a rollback you will have a much wider window of opporotunity to prove you are indeed capable of this position. As such, I think you are ready for RB. GL! {contribs) TropicalStormChapsteck {talkpage) NHCTSSymbol.png 04:29, May 18, 2019 (UTC)
  • Symbol neutral vote Neutral — I'm honest here, I do appreciate your efforts to moderate the chat, but like others said, you seem to not enforce the rules much, and I fear that might be the same thing for rollback. You're a nice, mature user though. I know you had reason for less activity, but I hope it "Will" be back sooner so I could support it. (yes, pun intended) Right now, I'm neutral. Best of luck Will! -- Farm River (talk) 12:45, May 18, 2019 (UTC)
  • Symbol arrow up Neutral, leaning support — While you do a good job being mature, and following the rules and such, I do often see you type random stuff, and you could still do a better job with enforcement. If you could improve your enforcement, I would fully support. Best of luck to you . - MASTERGARFIELD 13:04, May 18, 2019 (UTC)
  • Symbol oppose vote Oppose — Thank you for answering our concerns, Will. I did not expect to see that from you, but it does help us a bit here. Regardless, I am opposing for technical reasons: while you're still somewhat active here, your activity is quite different from the one back when you made your RfCM in December. You were more active back then, and while you do plan to be more active, I don't feel right now is the time for you to make this request. You have been moderating the chat less than usual, and while you have been doing that more recently, and you are a mature user, I do not believe now is time for it. Had you been more active, I would have supported this request, but currently, there is too much uncertainty regarding this. Good luck!
  • Symbol arrow up Neutral, leaning support — I think you would be a good rollback, but I will concur with my fellow administration members about your activity. Although rollback is mainly a wiki right, your responsibilities as chat moderator also remain, and as my fellow admins have pointed out, we have not seen much of that from you. However, I am quite willing to give you a chance with rollback, and I think you are fit for the role. Good luck!. Money Hurricane (talk) 15:44, May 18, 2019 (UTC)
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.